Home › Loan Programs › ARM vs Fixed

ARM vs Fixed

Adjustable or fixed: is the lower ARM rate worth the risk on a Sonoma County mortgage?

An ARM isn't the villain it was in 2007, and it isn't free money either. It's a trade. You get a lower rate for a set number of years, and in exchange you take on what happens after. Here's how I help clients decide if that trade is a good one.

The short version

A fixed-rate mortgage has one rate for the life of the loan. An adjustable-rate mortgage, or ARM, has a fixed rate for the first 5, 7 or 10 years, then adjusts with the market every six months after that, within limits called caps.

My rule of thumb: an ARM makes sense when the rate is meaningfully lower than the fixed, you have a believable reason you'll sell or pay the loan down before it adjusts, and you could survive the worst-case payment if your plan falls apart. Miss any one of those three and I'd take the fixed. Most of my clients do.

How does an adjustable-rate mortgage actually work?

Take the most common one I write, the 7/6 ARM. The 7 means the rate is locked for the first seven years. The 6 means that after year seven it can change every six months. It's still a 30-year loan with a normal principal-and-interest payment. No interest-only tricks, no negative amortization. Those were the loans that blew up in 2008, and they're mostly gone.

When the fixed period ends, the new rate is built from two pieces: an index and a margin. The index is a published market rate, typically the 30-day average SOFR on today's loans. The margin is a fixed number the lender adds on top, often somewhere around 2.75% to 3%. Index plus margin equals your new rate, subject to the caps.

The margin never changes, and it's written into your note on day one. So ask for it. Two ARMs with the same start rate and different margins are not the same loan.

What are ARM caps, and how bad can the payment get?

Caps are the guardrails. You'll see them written as three numbers, like 5/1/5. On a typical 7/6 or 10/6 ARM that means the rate can rise up to 5 points at the first adjustment, up to 1 point at each six-month adjustment after, and never more than 5 points above the start rate over the life of the loan. A 5/6 ARM usually has a tighter first cap of 2 points. Cap structures vary by lender and program, so read yours.

Here's the math I walk every ARM client through. Say you borrow $700,000 on a 7/6 ARM at 6.125%. The payment is about $4,253 a month. If rates went straight to the ceiling, the rate would hit 11.125% and the payment on the remaining balance would land around $6,300. That's roughly $2,000 a month more.

Is that likely? No. It would take a rough rate environment and you doing nothing for seven years. But it's possible, and I won't write an ARM for someone who hasn't looked at that number and said, out loud, "I could handle that or I'd have options." These rates are for illustration only. Current pricing changes daily, so verify for your scenario.

How much does an ARM really save?

Same $700,000 loan. Suppose the 30-year fixed is at 6.75% and the 7/6 ARM is at 6.125%. The fixed payment runs about $4,540. The ARM is about $4,253. That's roughly $285 a month, or around $24,000 over the seven fixed years, and you'd owe a little less principal at the end too.

That spread is the whole ballgame, and it moves around. Some months ARMs price a half point or more below the fixed. Other months the gap is an eighth of a point, and at that point the ARM is all risk and no reward. I've had stretches where I didn't quote a single one because the numbers were pointless.

Where I see the gap hold up most consistently is on jumbo loans. Banks keep a lot of those on their own books and price ARMs aggressively to get them. With Sonoma County's conforming limit sitting well under what a house costs in Healdsburg or the east side of Sonoma, plenty of local buyers land in jumbo territory, and that's where it pays to ask for both quotes.

Who should take the ARM, and who should stick with fixed?

The question I ask is simple: where will this loan be in seven years? Not the house. The loan. The average mortgage gets paid off or refinanced long before year 30, but average doesn't help you if you're the exception.

  • Good ARM fit: you're buying a starter place in Rohnert Park or Windsor and you already know you'll outgrow it in five or six years.
  • Good ARM fit: a job that relocates you on a schedule. Coast Guard families at Two Rock and traveling medical staff come up a lot here.
  • Good ARM fit: a large payoff is coming. Stock vesting, a business sale, an inheritance or the proceeds from another property that will knock the balance down before the first adjustment.
  • Good ARM fit: high earners on a jumbo loan who have the reserves to absorb an adjustment and would rather keep the savings working elsewhere.
  • Stick with fixed: this is the house you plan to retire in, or your budget is tight at the start rate.
  • Stick with fixed: your plan is "I'll just refinance before it adjusts." That's a hope, not a plan. Refinancing takes a job, decent credit, enough equity and rates that cooperate. You may not have all four on the day you need them.

Is it harder to qualify for an ARM?

Sometimes, and it catches people off guard. On shorter ARMs, like a 5/6, lenders generally have to qualify you at a rate higher than the start rate, to prove you could handle an early increase. So the loan with the lowest payment can actually be the hardest one to get approved for if your debt-to-income ratio is already stretched. On 7- and 10-year ARMs, conventional guidelines typically let you qualify at the note rate. Rules differ by program, so I check this before anyone falls in love with a payment.

FHA and VA both offer ARMs too, with their own cap structures. They're less common, and the pricing advantage is often thin, but for a VA buyer who knows orders are coming in a few years they're worth a look.

One more thing. Ask whether the ARM has a prepayment penalty. Most owner-occupied ARMs I see don't, but some bank portfolio and investor loans do, and a penalty defeats the whole idea of getting out early.

What should I ask before I sign an ARM?

If a lender quotes you an ARM and can't answer these in about a minute, find another lender.

  • What's the index, and what's the margin?
  • What are the caps: first adjustment, each adjustment after, and lifetime?
  • What's my payment at the lifetime cap, in dollars?
  • What would the rate adjust to if it reset today, based on the current index plus margin?
  • Is there a prepayment penalty?
  • What's the fixed-rate quote for the same loan on the same day, with the same points?
Questions

Frequently asked

Is an ARM a good idea right now?

Only if the ARM rate is meaningfully below the fixed rate and you expect to sell, pay down or refinance before the first adjustment. When the gap between the two is small, the fixed rate is usually the better choice because you're taking on risk without much savings. Pricing changes daily, so compare both quotes for your scenario.

What does 7/6 ARM mean?

The rate is fixed for the first seven years, then adjusts every six months for the rest of the 30-year term. A 5/6 ARM is fixed for five years and a 10/6 ARM for ten. Longer fixed periods usually come with a slightly higher start rate.

Can my ARM rate go down?

Yes. After the fixed period the rate follows the index plus your margin, so it can drop if market rates fall. Most ARMs have a floor, often the margin itself, that the rate can't go below.

Can I refinance an ARM into a fixed-rate mortgage later?

Yes, as long as you qualify at that time. You'll need sufficient income, credit and equity, and you'll pay closing costs again. It's a reasonable backup, but it shouldn't be the only exit you're counting on.

Are ARMs available on jumbo loans in Sonoma County?

Yes, and jumbo is where ARMs are most common locally. Many banks hold jumbo ARMs in their own portfolios and price them below their 30-year fixed jumbo rates. Terms, caps and reserve requirements vary a lot between lenders.

Ready when you are

Want the ARM and the fixed quoted side by side?

Tell me the price range, your down payment and how long you honestly expect to keep the loan. I'll price both on the same day and show you the savings, the caps and the worst-case payment in dollars, so you're choosing with the full picture. Call Jesse at 707-595-5393.